The Unknown Final Resting Place of Herman Lutter

In a quest to discover the burial location of Herman Lutter (1860-1924), my great great grandfather, I procured further documents relating to the disposition of his estate.

Herman was a resident of Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, from the time of his immigration around 1881 until the early 1920s. According to the 1922 Newark City Directory, Herman moved to Asbury Park.

Clara R Lutter (born Uhl) was Herman's first wife and the mother of Howard Lutter.

Herman died July 3, 1924.

Where was he buried? This is a standard question for everyone I study.

The death certificate and obituary list Fairmount as his final resting place. This is a large cemetery on the outskirts of the City of Newark. Both of Herman's wives are buried here.

But- Fairmount Cemetery has no record of receiving Herman's body. He was not buried in the days following his death on July 3, 1924. He has no individual plot. He is not listed in the plots with his wives. He is not listed in any mausoleum. 

Death of Herman Lutter
July 3, 1924 in Wall, Monmouth County, New Jersey

Obituary of Herman Lutter
The Newark Evening News is online and searchable for free for the years 1883-1926.

Manger Funeral home lists the place of interment as Fairview Cemetery, not Fairmount. No town was listed. I contacted three cemeteries of this name in New Jersey. All denied having a record of Herman:

Fairview Cemetery in Fairview, Bergen County

Fairview Cemetery in Westfield, Union County

Fair View Cemetery in Middletown, Monmouth County

Manger Funeral Home, Newark, New Jersey
(Project of the New Jersey Records Preservation Group)

Herman's will provided at least $600 for a headstone.

Someone (thank you M. L.) suggested I obtain copies of the accounting to find out who made the headstone and where it was delivered. So I wrote to Monmouth County. His will was probated in Monmouth County because he was a resident of Spring Lake in Monmouth County. No proceedings were listed in Essex County. 

You can find an index of proceedings for twenty of New Jersey's 21 counties at FamilySearch.org. (Morris County was removed.)

Unfortunately, no accounting was found. The only available documents were releases signed by the devisees to receive money from Herman's estate- $659 each to four people. No mention of a headstone.

The nieces and nephew named in the will:

• Gussie Kitson, daughter of Herman's brother, Otto Luther or Lutter (1845-1909)
• Paul, Edeline, and Anna Michel, children of Herman's sister, Ottillia

The names and locations of the people who signed releases helped me to further trace their lines:

• Gussie Kittson, daughter of Otto Lutter, signed in Harrison, Hudson County, New Jersey on January 6, 1926.
• Anna Heym, born Michel, signed in Neuhaus, Thueringen, Germany on March 4, 1926.
• Edeline Vorwerk, born Michel, signed in Germina, Saxony, Germany on March 16, 1926.
• Mina Michel signed in South Orange, Essex County, New Jersey on March 31, 1926.

Paul Michel, the third child of Ottillia, did not sign a release and there was no explanation of his absence.

I did not know who Mina Michel was and why she signed a release, as she was not mentioned in the will, but was delighted to see that she resided in nearby South Orange.

The next articles discuss these people.